Book Discussion Which version of the Orphic Hymns do you think is better? Sara Mastros, Patrick Dunn, or another version?

[MagickalStudent569]

I've been going through both books recently. I used to have physical copy of Patrick's that I've sense lost so I'm already quite familiar with his. Sara's, that I've been going through, seems a lot more whimsical and based on her own person UPG in edition to historical research. Definitely a less traditional approach but none the less unique. What do you guys think of each of these books personally? Is one better than the other or are older versions superior? I'm open to any and all feedback.

 

[HoldAll]

You might want to look at this thread:

Book Discussion - Comparing 5 Orphic Hymn translations: Selene, Hermes, Kronos

"Which translation of the Orphic hymns should I use?" "Which is the best translation of the Orphic hymns?" You decide! Below are the translations for Selene, Hermes and Kronos from the following books: The Orphic Hymns by Patrick Dunn (2018) Tamra Lucid and Ronnie Pontiac (2023)* Apostolos N...

wizardforums.com

 

[MagickalStudent569]

You might want to look at this thread:

Book Discussion - Comparing 5 Orphic Hymn translations: Selene, Hermes, Kronos

"Which translation of the Orphic hymns should I use?" "Which is the best translation of the Orphic hymns?" You decide! Below are the translations for Selene, Hermes and Kronos from the following books: The Orphic Hymns by Patrick Dunn (2018) Tamra Lucid and Ronnie Pontiac (2023)* Apostolos N...

wizardforums.com

Oh I guess I missed that one when I searched earlier. Thanks!