- Joined
- Apr 16, 2021
- Messages
- 175
- Reaction score
- 395
- Awards
- 7
I was talking within the specific lens of "movie style magic"... things like throwing fireballs around and stuff, as per the question of the original poster. But I do agree that for things that are more subtle than a brick to the face, magic is still as effective as it always has been. It's the flashy stuff that got a hard nerf by societal changes.Magicians have always had to work in spite of humanity - that is why the most effective magical workings are performed alone, and why, if you need to work with other people, rituals and suchlike are required to make sure everyone is on the same page and working as a unit. If you tell anyone not involved, about the magical act before it is complete, you've then involved them too, and their contribution is likely to just be noise to your signal.
What I discovered in my research is that success is nurtured by increasing a) the number of possible results that count as a success and b) the amount of ignorance that you have about how that success might happen.
On the other side, high speed communication through the internet has thrown into sharp relief how credulous people can be, as "a lie can be halfway round the world before the truth has its boots on" as Terry Pratchett put it.
Large scale magic nowadays is less about imposing your belief system directly and more about manipulating peoples' existing belief systems to get them to do what you want, in spite of any facts that might get in your way.
So, I believe that magic is just as potent as it ever was, but the methods used to successfully apply it have changed. All the more effective if the people you are manipulating by magic don't believe in it.